Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Resource adequacy (RA) is the ability of an electricity system to reliably satisfy loads using its available resources. Assessing and maintaining RA is becoming more challenging due to increasing coal plant retirements, penetration of wind and solar resources, reliance on bilateral and market transactions, and emerging technologies. RA evaluation and planning have traditionally been conducted by utilities and overseen by their state regulators using integrated resource planning (IRP) processes. However, the Northwest Power Pool (NWPP) is developing a proposal for a regional RA program in the Western U.S. that would set and enforce capacity obligations for member utilities, and achieve RA more cost-effectively by pooling resources and load profiles from across the region. In this paper, we investigate the policy implications of a regional RA program for existing IRP regulations, with the proposed NWPP RA program as our main object of study. We compile the RA assessment practices of Western U.S. utilities, the proposed NWPP RA program design, and lessons from the historical experience of the Southwest Power Pool's RA program. Our analysis reveals that the IRP components which would be most heavily impacted by the regional program are RA targets, load forecasts, capacity accreditation factors, and transmission upgrades. We conclude by discussing the policy issues that RA program design and state IRP policy would have to address.