Nitrogenase employs a sophisticated electron transfer system and a Mo-Fe-S-C cofactor, designated the M-cluster [(cit)MoFe7 S9 C]), to reduce atmospheric N2 to bioaccessible NH3 . Previously, we have shown that the cofactor-free form of nitrogenase can be repurposed as a protein scaffold for the incorporation of a synthetic Fe-S cluster [Fe6 S9 (SEt)2 ]4- . Here, we demonstrate the utility of an asymmetric Mo-Fe-S cluster [Cp*MoFe5 S9 (SH)]3- as an alternative artificial cofactor upon incorporation into the cofactor-free nitrogenase scaffold. The resultant semi-artificial enzyme catalytically reduces C2 H2 to C2 H4 , and CN- into short-chain hydrocarbons, yet it is clearly distinct in activity from its [Fe6 S9 (SEt)2 ]4- -reconstituted counterpart, pointing to the possibility to employ molecular design and cluster synthesis strategies to further develop semi-artificial or artificial systems with desired catalytic activities.