Coastal regions are the world’s most densely populated areas, directly supporting some of the most biodiverse habitats, as well as trillions of dollars’ worth of ecosystem goods and services.
As the interface between terrestrial and marine habitats, these areas are subject to numerous
stressors, which when co-occurring with one another, can have interacting effects that pose a
direct risk to coastal ecosystems, the rich aquatic life their harbor, and the services they provide
to people. To effectively allocate resources towards and proactively manage against these threats,
we must first understand their spatiotemporal patterns and how stressors impact our coastal
ecosystems. My dissertation aims to uncover global patterns of risks to coastal ecosystem health
across coral reefs, seagrass meadows, and kelp forests, three critical coastal ecosystems that have
been in decline for decades. My studies answer questions about the past and current state of
thermal and water quality stress along global coasts, uneven exposure to stressors across
protected area statuses, potential economic losses in fish catch landings in impaired ecosystems,
and the changing prevalence of diseases across the world's two largest coral reefs, the Great
Barrier Reef and the Mesoamerican Reef. Insights from these analyses can help inform
management decisions for the preservation of our coastal ecosystems towards the future.
In the first data chapter, I analyzed global mean monthly trends using remotely sensed sea
surface temperature (SST) and chlorophyll-a data over the 25-year period from 1998-2022 as
proxies for global thermal stress and local water quality stress on coral reefs, seagrass meadows,
and kelp forests. I found that in all three marine coastal ecosystems over 50% of their respective
global habitat areas have undergone increases in both thermal and water quality stress over the
study period. Next, comparing protected and not protected areas, there was no difference in
thermal stress trends as all ecosystems, regardless of protection status, as they all experienced
increases. By contrast, trends in water quality stress trends were heterogeneous across habitats
and between protection status, indicating that our current matrix of protected areas are
differentially experiencing water quality stress and that protected area positive gains are
potentially being undermined or erased by poor water quality. Finally, by establishing
associations between fish taxa and coastal ecosystems, I found that landed fish catch associated
with coral reefs, seagrass meadows, and kelp forests to be valued at $33.9 billion year-1, with
one-third of that value experiencing an increase in both thermal and water quality stress. With
this information, there is a detailed inventory of regions by their levels of thermal and water
quality stress. Debate continues as to whether we should invest our resources, including
protected areas, in the most affected regions to try to limit their further decline, or prioritize
pristine areas as they may have a higher likelihood of conservation success.
In the second data chapter, I assess risk to coastal ecosystems by using decadal datasets
from two largest coral reef systems in the world. Intensifying climate and anthropogenic
pressures have been identified as a causal agent in the development of coral diseases, with
exposure to these stressors being implicated as a causal agent of disease development.
Disturbances in host, pathogen, environment, or all, can lead to periodic disease outbreaks that
can decimate coral populations and cause shifts in coral community assemblages. I analyzed over
1.1 million corals in the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) from 2004-2016 and over 54,000 corals in the
Mesoamerican Reef (MAR) from 2005-2018 to evaluate spatiotemporal patterns of coral disease.
Contrary to the expected results, disease prevalence dropped by 87.1% in the GBR and 49.3% in
the MAR. Investigating further, I found health prevalence decreased in the GBR from 96.1% to
83.6% and increased in the MAR from 73.5% to 81.4%. Coral density in the GBR plummeted
from 21.15 to 8.45 corals per m² in just thirteen years, while the MAR's coral density did not
change. Average community composition shifted significantly in the GBR, and community
composition dispersion shrunk. Significant interactions were found between coral disease and
accumulated thermal and water quality stressors, indicating their synergistic effect. Collectively,
these results demonstrate the cryptic nature of disease patterns. While disease prevalence can
increase or decrease in coral reefs systems, the causes of those fluctuations needs to be further
investigated to explore the root cause of the changes and their relationship to disease.
These studies highlight the dynamic nature of coastal ecosystem health, and the need for
long-term monitoring, both across spatial scales and across sampling methodologies, to gain
insights into the risks our coastal ecosystems face. Studies have shown that the recovery of
marine populations is possible if major pressures, like climate change, were mitigated. While this
is an ambitious proposition, it shows the strength and resiliency of these ecosystems when
supported with favorable conditions and highlights the need for swift, actionable, and optimistic
action.