Background

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is a rare condition usually diagnosed in patients with classic thyroid function tests (TFTs) of elevated thyroid hormone levels with nonsuppressed TSH. The presence of autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD) can confound the clinical diagnosis of RTH. A family was evaluated because several members had elevated TSH and normal or low serum T4 concentrations with AITD. While these individuals were initially reported to have RTH, they were found to have a normal thyroid hormone receptor beta (THRB) gene sequence, and three other asymptomatic family members were found to harbor the variant TRβ G339S.

Methods

The THRB gene was sequenced in 19 members of a large Mexican/Aztec family. In vitro expression of the mutant TRβ protein was performed, as well as computer modeling of the variant compared to known mutations in the flanking codons.

Results

Investigation of an individual with AITD who was incorrectly diagnosed with RTH led to the fortuitous discovery of a THRB gene variant (G339S) in the proposita's father, paternal aunt, and cousin. This variant was not detected in analysis of 124 unrelated alleles. All individuals harboring G339S had normal TFTs. Normal in vitro expression and function of G339S and molecular modeling predicted that this variant would not have an effect on the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid axis as determined by thyroid hormone binding in vitro and thyroid function tests in vivo, despite profound effects seen in mutations in the adjacent codons 338 and 340.

Conclusion

We report an individual with normal TFTs and AITD harboring a novel THRB gene variant. In addition to illustrating the importance of accurate diagnosis of thyroid disease so that proper treatment and counseling can be given, TRβ codon 339 is not essential for normal TRβ function.

Mutations in the cell membrane thyroid hormone (TH) transporter monocarboxylate transporter (MCT) 8 produce severe neuropsychomotor defects and characteristic thyroid function test (TFT) abnormalities. Two children with mild neurological phenotypes and normal TFTs were found to harbor MCT8 gene variants of unknown significance (VUS), MCT8-R388Q that occurred de novo, and MCT8-Q212E. Normal TH transport and action in fibroblasts of MCT8-R388Q was demonstrated in a novel nonradioactive functional assay measuring the intracellular TH availability after L-T3 treatment. No genotype-phenotype correlation was found in additional family members carrying MCT8-Q212E. For the field of MCT8 deficiency, it is important to assess the significance of MCT8 gene VUS.