Abstract : We study the effective potentials for various probe branes surrounding AdS4 black holes with massive halos in consistent truncations of M-theory on the Sasaki-Einstein7 manifolds Q111 and M111. These probes are either M2 branes extended in spacetime or “particle-like” probes such as internally wrapped M2 branes and, upon reduction to type IIA String theory, D6 branes corresponding to baryon operators in the dual Chern-Simons theory. We find both global and local minima of the potential outside the horizon, indicating the existence of stable and metastable multicenter AdS black holes in the extreme mass ratio regime, at fixed temperature and charges. For the planar case, we also find an instability towards nucleation of spacetime-filling M2 branes. With this analysis, we address some open questions on the holographic description of glassy phases of matter.