A 1976 chemical factory explosion near Seveso, Italy exposed residents to high levels of 2,3,7,8-tetracholorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD or dioxin). Dioxin is a known human carcinogen and potent endocrine disruptor. It is highly lipophilic and has a long half-life in humans. Much of what we know and can learn about the risks of dioxin exposure on human health arose from the tragic circumstances of Seveso. This review aims to describe the Seveso accident, summarize the results of 40 years of research on the health of the Seveso population since the accident, and discuss next-stage research on the health of Seveso residents, their children, and grandchildren.

Background

Prenatal 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) exposure has been shown to alter sexual differentiation of the brain in animal models, impacting pubertal development, behavior, cortical dominance, and cognition. The effects of early life exposure to dioxin-like compounds on human neurodevelopment, however, are less clear and warrant further investigation.

Methods

The Seveso Women's Health Study (SWHS), initiated in 1996, is a well-characterized cohort of 981 Italian women who lived in proximity to an industrial accident in July 1976 that resulted in one of the highest residential TCDD exposures on record. In 2014-2016, we enrolled offspring born after the accident into the Seveso Second Generation Health Study. Children aged 7-17 years old (n = 161) completed a neuropsychological assessment spanning executive function and reverse learning (Wisconsin Card Sort), non-verbal intelligence (Raven's Progressive Matrices), attention and hyperactivity (Connor's Continuous Performance (CPT), and memory (Rey's Auditory Verbal Learning). We used multivariate regression with robust standard error estimates accounting for clustering of siblings to model the associations between these outcomes and prenatal exposure defined as TCDD measured in maternal serum collected soon after the explosion and estimated to pregnancy.

Results

The children (82 male, 79 female) averaged 13.1 (±2.9) years of age. Adjusting for covariates, a 10-fold increase in maternal serum TCDD was not adversely associated with reverse learning/set-shifting, memory, attention/impulsivity, or non-verbal intelligence. In sex-stratified models, prenatal TCDD was associated with more non-perseverative errors in boys but not in girls (p_int = 0.04). TCDD was also associated with attention deficits on the CPT but only among children with the shortest breastfeeding histories.

Conclusions

While overall, there were no significant associations, the observed differential neurotoxic sensitivities to TCDD by sex and lactation history may warrant confirmation in future studies.

Background/objectives

In utero exposure to endocrine-disrupting compounds such as 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) may alter risk of obesity and related metabolic disease later in life. We examined the relationship of prenatal exposure to TCDD with obesity and metabolic syndrome (MetS) in children born to a unique cohort of TCDD-exposed women resulting from a 1976 explosion in Seveso, Italy.

Subjects/methods

In 2014, nearly 40 years after the explosion, we enrolled 611 post-explosion offspring, 2 to 39 years of age, in the Seveso Second Generation Study. In utero TCDD exposure was defined primarily as TCDD concentration measured in maternal serum collected soon after the explosion and alternately as TCDD estimated at pregnancy. We measured height, weight, waist circumference, body fat, blood pressure, and fasting blood levels of lipids and glucose, which were combined to assess body mass index (BMI) and MetS.

Results

Children (314 female, 297 male) averaged 23.6 (±6.0) years of age. Among the 431 children ≥18 years, a 10-fold increase in initial maternal TCDD concentration was inversely associated with BMI in daughters (adj-β = -0.99 kg/m²; 95% CI -1.86, -0.12), but not sons (adj-β = 0.41 kg/m²; 95% CI -0.35, 1.18) (p-int = 0.02). A similar relationship was found in the younger children (2-17 years); a 10-fold increase in initial maternal TCDD was inversely associated with BMI z-score (adj-β = -0.59 kg/m²; 95% CI -1.12, -0.06) among daughters, but not sons (adj-β = 0.04 kg/m²; 95% CI -0.34, 0.41) (p-int = 0.03). In contrast, in sons only, initial maternal TCDD was associated with increased risk for MetS (adj-RR = 2.09, 95% CI 1.09, 4.02). Results for TCDD estimated at pregnancy were comparable.

Conclusions

These results suggest prenatal TCDD exposure alters cardiometabolic endpoints in a sex-specific manner. In daughters, in utero TCDD is inversely associated with adiposity measures. In sons, in utero TCDD is associated with increased risk for MetS.

Background

In animal studies, perinatal exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) alters thyroid homoeostasis and thyroid hormone concentrations; epidemiologic evidence is limited.

Objectives

We aimed to determine the association of prenatal exposure to TCDD with thyroid hormone concentrations in the Seveso Second Generation Study, a unique cohort of children born to TCDD-exposed women resulting from a 1976 chemical factory explosion in Seveso, Italy.

Methods

We included 570 children (288 female, 282 male) with complete follow-up data, including a fasting blood draw. Serum levels of total and free thyroxine (T4), free triiodothyronine (T3), and thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) were measured using immunoassays. We defined prenatal TCDD exposure as: 1) maternal initial TCDD concentration measured in serum collected soon after the explosion and 2) maternal TCDD estimated at pregnancy.

Results

Compared to the lowest quartile (Q1), maternal initial serum TCDD was associated with lower free T3 (Q2: adj-β = -0.13, 95%CI -0.26, 0.00; Q3: adj-β = -0.22, 95%CI -0.35, -0.09; Q4: adj-β = -0.14, 95%CI -0.28, 0.00; p-trend = 0.02). In participants with high thyroid antibody status, inverse associations between maternal initial serum TCDD and free T3 were significantly stronger than in participants with normal antibody status (p-interaction = 0.02). We also observed a positive association between maternal initial serum TCDD and TSH concentrations in participants with high thyroid antibody status (Q2: adj-β = 11.4%, 95%CI -25.2, 66.1; Q3: adj-β = 49.0%, 95%CI 3.0, 115.5; Q4: adj-β = 105.5, 95%CI 36.6, 209.2; p-trend < 0.01) but not in those participants with normal antibody status (p-interaction < 0.01). Similar results were found for TCDD estimated at pregnancy.

Discussion

Our results suggest prenatal exposure to TCDD, a potent endocrine-disrupting compound, may alter thyroid function later in life. Populations with additional thyroid stress may be particularly susceptible to in utero exposure of thyroid disrupting chemicals.

Background

Exposure to endocrine disrupting compounds such as 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) during susceptible developmental windows may alter risk of metabolic disease later in life. Animal studies of in utero and lactational TCDD exposure report associations with alterations in insulin sensitivity and energy homeostasis, but epidemiologic evidence is limited. We examined the relationship of prenatal TCDD exposure with markers of glucose homeostasis in the Seveso Second Generation study, a unique cohort of children born to TCDD-exposed women resulting from a 1976 explosion in Seveso, Italy.

Methods

We included 426 children who were 18 years or older with complete follow-up data including a fasting blood draw. Insulin and glucose were measured and the updated homoeostatic model assessment was used to estimate insulin resistance (HOMA2-IR) and beta-cell function (HOMA2-B). Prenatal TCDD exposure was defined in two ways, as initial maternal serum TCDD concentration and TCDD estimated at pregnancy.

Results

The children (222 female, 204 male) averaged 28.6 (±6.0) years. We found a 10-fold increase in TCDD estimated at pregnancy was inversely associated with insulin (adj-β = -1.24 μIU/mL, 95% confidence interval (CI): -2.38, -0.09) and HOMA2-B (adj-β = -10.2% decrease, 95% CI: -17.8, -1.9) among daughters, but not sons (insulin: adj-β = 0.57 μIU/mL, 95% CI: -0.84, 1.98, P for interaction = 0.04; and HOMA2-B: adj-β = 0.8% increase, 95% CI -10.7, 13.9, P for interaction = 0.11). Similar effect modification was observed for TCDD estimated at pregnancy and HOMA2-IR (P for interaction = 0.13). The models for initial maternal serum TCDD showed similar effect modification by child sex. The observed associations in daughters showed evidence of mediation by body mass index, which we have previously found to be associated with prenatal TCDD exposure in female offspring.

Conclusion

These results suggest prenatal exposure to TCDD is associated with lower insulin resistance and beta compensation in female offspring, and show evidence of mediation by body mass index.

Background

2, 3, 7, 8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) is proposed to interfere with fetal growth via altered activity of the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (protein: AHR; gene: AHR) pathway which regulates diverse biological and developmental processes including xenobiotic metabolism. Genetic variation in AHR is an important driver of susceptibility to low birthweight in children exposed to prenatal smoking, but less is known about these genetic interactions with TCDD, AHR's most potent xenobiotic ligand.

Methods

The Seveso Women's Health Study (SWHS), initiated in 1996, is a cohort of 981 Italian women exposed to TCDD from an industrial explosion in July 1976. We measured TCDD concentrations in maternal serum collected close to the time of the accident. In 2008 and 2014, we followed up the SWHS cohort and collected data on birth outcomes of SWHS women with post-accident pregnancies. We genotyped 19 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in AHR among the 574 SWHS mothers.

Results

Among 901 singleton births, neither SNPs nor TCDD exposure alone were significantly associated with birthweight. However, we found six individual SNPs in AHR which adversely modified the association between maternal TCDD and birthweight, implicating gene-environment interaction. We saw an even stronger susceptibility to TCDD due to interaction when we examined the joint contribution of these SNPs in a risk allele score. These SNPs were all located in noncoding regions of AHR, particularly in proximity to the promoter.

Conclusions

This is the first study to demonstrate that genetic variation across the maternal AHR gene may shape fetal susceptibilities to TCDD exposure.

Study question

Is there an association between 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) exposure and fecundability and infertility among Seveso women and their daughters?

Summary answer

TCDD exposure is associated with a decrease in fecundability and increased risk of infertility in women, as well as their daughters.

What is known already

In animal studies, maternal exposure to TCDD is associated with decreased fertility in offspring. Effects of TCDD are mediated by activation of the aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR) pathway.

Study design, size, duration

The Seveso Women's Health Study (SWHS) has followed 981 women exposed to TCDD in a 1976 accident since 1996. In 2014, we initiated the Seveso Second Generation Study to follow-up their children.

Participants/materials, setting, methods

We obtained information on pregnancy history including time of trying to conceive from SWHS women and their daughters who were 18 years or older. We considered TCDD exposure as initial 1976 serum TCDD concentration and estimated TCDD at pregnancy. We examined relationships of TCDD exposure with time to pregnancy (TTP, the monthly probability of conception within the first 12 months of trying) and infertility (≥12 months of trying to conceive). We also assessed contributions of polymorphisms in the AHR pathway via genetic risk score.

Main results and the role of chance

Among SWHS women (n = 446), median TTP was 3 months and 18% reported taking ≥12 months to conceive. Initial 1976 TCDD (log10) was associated with longer TTP (adjusted fecundability odds ratio = 0.82; 95% CI 0.68-0.98) and increased risk of infertility (adjusted relative risk = 1.35; 95% CI 1.01-1.79). TCDD at pregnancy yielded similar associations. Among SWHS daughters (n = 66), median TTP was 2 months and 11% reported taking ≥12 months to conceive. Daughters showed similar, but non-significant, associations with maternal TCDD exposure.

Limitations, reasons for caution

A limitation of this study is time to pregnancy was reported retrospectively, although previous studies have found women are able to recall time to conception with a high degree of accuracy many years after the fact. The number of SWHS daughters who had a live birth was small and we were unable to examine fecundability of SWHS sons.

Wider implications of the findings

Consistent with previous findings in animal studies, our study found that TCDD exposure may be associated with decreased fertility in Seveso mothers and potentially in their daughters exposed in utero. There may be susceptible genetic subgroups. The literature has largely considered the genetics of the AHR pathway in the context of male fertility but not female fertility, despite strong biological plausibility. These findings should be replicated in larger populations and of different ancestry. Future studies in Seveso should examine the sons and the grandchildren of exposed mothers given the animal literature suggesting potential heritable epigenetic effects.

Study funding/competing interest(s)

This study was supported by grant numbers F06 TW02075-01 from the National Institutes of Health, R01 ES07171 and 2P30-ESO01896-17 from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, R82471 from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and #2896 from Regione Lombardia and Fondazione Lombardia Ambiente, Milan, Italy. J.A. was supported by F31ES026488 from the National Institutes of Health. The authors declare they have no actual or potential competing financial interests.

Trial registration number

N/A.