It has long been postulated that pathogenic events during fetal development influence atherosclerosis-related diseases later in life, but the mechanisms involved are unknown. This review focuses on the evidence indicating that maternal hypercholesterolemia during pregnancy is responsible for one cascade of pathogenic events. Maternal hypercholesterolemia is associated with greatly increased fatty streak formation in human fetal arteries and accelerated progression of atherosclerosis during childhood. Recent experiments in genetically more homogeneous rabbits established that temporary diet-induced maternal hypercholesterolemia is sufficient to enhance fetal lesion formation. More important, maternal hypercholesterolemia or ensuing pathogenic events in the fetus increase postnatal atherogenesis in response to hypercholesterolemia. Maternal treatment with cholesterol-lowering agents or antioxidants greatly reduces fetal and postnatal atherogenesis, indicating a pathogenic role of lipid peroxidation and a potential involvement of oxidation-sensitive signaling pathways. Experiments in a murine model showed that differences in arterial gene expression between offspring of normo- and hypercholesterolemic mothers persist long after birth, supporting the assumption that fetal lesion formation is associated with genetic programming, which may in turn affect postnatal atherogenesis. A better understanding of pathogenic programming events in utero may lead to the identification of genes determining the susceptibility to atherosclerosis and define novel preventive approaches.

It is increasingly recognized that the in utero environment is an important determinant of adult disease, and extensive epidemiological evidence links dysmetabolic conditions during pregnancy with increased hypertension, cardiovascular disease, and diabetes later in life. The original Barker Hypothesis focused on low birth weight as the primary indicator of postnatal risk, but low birth weight may arise from other, non-metabolic conditions. This has impeded the identification of developmental programming mechanisms. More recently, the focus has shifted to the impact of specific maternal risk factors, such as obesity, metabolic syndrome, and diabetes, on cardiovascular risk in offspring. Inflammation plays a central role in these maternal conditions as well as in offspring atherogenesis, and two key factors that influence inflammation, maternal hypercholesterolemia and maternal immune mechanisms, have been shown to affect the developmental programming of atherosclerosis. Maternal hypercholesterolemia in pregnancy, even if only temporary, is associated with increased fatty streak formation in human fetal arteries and accelerated progression of atherosclerosis in normocholesterolemic children. Conversely, immunization of experimental animals with oxidized low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, an antigen prevalent in atherosclerotic lesions, inhibits the progression of atherosclerosis in the offspring of hypercholesterolemic mothers. These findings indicate it is possible, in principle, to program postnatal immune responses and to reduce atherosclerosis, and potentially other immunomodulated diseases, by targeted maternal immunomodulation.

Pathogenic factors associated with maternal hypercholesterolemia, obesity, and diabetic conditions during pregnancy influence fetal development and predispose offspring to cardiovascular disease. Animal models have established cause–effect relationships consistent with epidemiological findings in humans and have demonstrated, in principle, that interventions before or during pregnancy can reduce or prevent pathogenic in utero programming. However, little is known about the mechanisms by which maternal dysmetabolic conditions enhance disease susceptibility in offspring. Identification of these mechanisms is rendered more difficult by the fact that programming effects in offspring may be latent and may require conventional risk factors and inherited genetic co-factors to become clinically manifest. Given the increasing prevalence of maternal risk factors, which is expected to lead to a wave of cardiovascular disease in the coming decades, and the length of prospective studies on developmental programming in humans, greater-than-usual emphasis on experimental models and translational studies is necessary.

We previously established that probucol decreases basal expression of VCAM-1 in the aorta of WHHL rabbits and inhibits the up-regulation of VCAM-1 expression that normally accompanies atherogenesis. To determine whether this effect is shared by other antioxidants in vivo, we now investigated whether a structurally unrelated antioxidant, vitamin E, also inhibits arterial VCAM-1 expression and whether the degree of VCAM-1 inhibition correlates with the reduction of atherosclerosis or the antioxidant protection of LDL. Atherogenesis and VCAM-1 mRNA and protein were determined in four groups of NZW rabbits (n = 6;-8) fed 0.5% cholesterol alone or supplemented with 0.1% vitamin E, a low dose (0.04;-0.075%) of probucol yielding the same degree of antioxidant protection of plasma LDL as vitamin E, or a high dose (0.5%) of probucol, and in normocholesterolemic rabbits. After 81 days, extensive atherosclerosis and a greater than 4-fold up-regulation of VCAM-1 mRNA was seen in rabbits on high cholesterol diet, mostly in the intima. Treatment with vitamin E, high-dose probucol, and low-dose probucol significantly decreased VCAM-1 mRNA by 49.0, 74.9, and 57. 5%, respectively, and reduced atherosclerosis in adjacent segments of the thoracic aorta to a similar degree as reported by previous studies. Immunocytochemistry confirmed that lesions of antioxidant-treated animals also contained less VCAM-1 protein. Neither the degree of VCAM-1 inhibition nor the extent of atherosclerosis correlated with the degree of antioxidant protection of plasma LDL.In summary, treatment with structurally unrelated antioxidants conveyed different degrees of antioxidant protection to plasma LDL but significantly reduced VCAM-1 expression in vivo and inhibited atherogenesis. This is consistent with the assumption that antiatherogenic effects of antioxidants may in part be mediated by interference with oxidation-dependent intracellular signaling.

Background

Atherosclerotic lesions in intracranial arteries occur later and are less extensive than in extracranial arteries. To investigate potential mechanisms responsible for this difference, in particular the atherogenic response to hypercholesterolemia and LDL oxidation, we compared the extent of fatty streak formation and the composition of these very early lesions in intracranial arteries of human fetuses from normocholesterolemic and hypercholesterolemic mothers with those in extracranial arteries.

Methods and results

Lesions were quantified by computer-assisted image analysis of 30 oil red O-stained sections, each from the middle cerebral, basilar, and common carotid arteries and the abdominal aorta of human fetuses (spontaneous abortions and premature newborns who died within 12 hours of birth; both of fetal age 6.2+/-1.3 months) from 43 hypercholesterolemic mothers and 34 normocholesterolemic mothers. Macrophages, apolipoprotein B, and 2 epitopes of oxidized LDL in lesions were determined immunocytochemically. Activities of superoxide dismutase, catalase, and glutathione peroxidase in the arterial wall were also determined. Lesion numbers and sizes were dramatically greater in the abdominal aorta (area of the largest lesion per section: 66.5+/-10.9 x10(3) microm2) and the carotid (11. 6+/-5.3 x10(3) microm2) than in the basilar and middle cerebral artery (0.4+/-0.1 and 0.8+/-0.2 x10(3) microm2, respectively; P<0. 0001). Hypercholesterolemia resulted in a significant increase of lesion size in extracranial arteries but only a marginal increase in intracranial arteries. In analogy, hypercholesterolemia induced a much greater increase in the intimal presence of macrophages, apolipoprotein B, and oxidized LDL (oxidation-specific epitopes) in extracranial than in intracranial arteries. Immunocytochemistry did not indicate that lesions of intracranial arteries contain relatively less oxidized LDL than similar-size lesions of extracranial arteries. Activities of Mn-superoxide dismutase but not of Zn-superoxide dismutase, catalase, or glutathione peroxidase were significantly higher in both intracranial arteries.

Conclusions

Exposure to hypercholesterolemia during fetal development results in extensive formation of fatty streaks in extracranial but not intracranial arteries. The fact that such a difference in lesion formation occurs in the absence of many other atherogenic risk factors found later in life suggests that differences in the atherogenic response to hypercholesterolemia are an important contributor to the slower onset of the disease in intracranial vessels in adults. Fetal arteries may allow elucidation of the mechanisms responsible, for example, better protection of intracranial arteries against free radical-mediated atherogenic processes.

Background

Children generally have low cholesterol and no clinical manifestations of atherosclerosis, but fatty-streak formation begins in fetuses and is greatly increased by maternal hypercholesterolaemia during pregnancy. In the FELIC study we assessed the evolution of such lesions during childhood.

Methods

Computer-assisted imaging was used to measure the area of the largest individual lesion and the cumulative lesion area per section in serial cross-sections through the entire aortic arch and abdominal aorta of 156 normocholesterolaemic children aged 1-13 years, who died of trauma and other causes. Children were classified by whether their mother had been normocholesterolaemic (n=97) or hypercholesterolaemic (n=59) during pregnancy. Atherosclerosis was correlated with 13 established or potential risk factors. Findings The largest fatty streaks in the aortic arch of children younger than 3 years of hypercholesterolaemic mothers were 64% smaller than those previously found in corresponding fetuses (p<0.0001), which suggests that fetal fatty streaks may regress after birth. In the two groups, lesion size in the aortic arch and abdominal aorta increased linearly with age (r=0.87-0.98). However, lesions progressed strikingly faster in children of hypercholesterolaemic mothers than in those of normocholesterolaemic mothers (p<0.0001). Conventional risk factors for atherosclerosis in children or mothers correlated with lesion size, but did not account for the faster progression of atherogenesis in normocholesterolaemic children of hypercholesterolaemic mothers.

Interpretation

Our results suggest that maternal hypercholesterolaemia during pregnancy induces changes in the fetal aorta that determine the long-term susceptibility of children to fatty-streak formation and subsequent atherosclerosis. If so, cholesterol-lowering interventions in hypercholesterolaemic mothers during pregnancy may decrease atherogenesis in children.

Maternal hypercholesterolemia during pregnancy is associated with a marked increase in aortic fatty streak formation in human fetuses and faster progression of atherosclerosis during normocholesterolemic childhood. However, the mechanisms responsible are unknown, and the contribution of genetic differences is difficult to assess in humans. The goal of this study was to determine whether maternal hypercholesterolemia per se may cause enhanced fatty streak formation in offspring and whether interventions during pregnancy can reduce it. During pregnancy, 1 group of New Zealand White rabbits was fed control chow and 8 groups were fed hypercholesterolemic diets Chol 1 (yielding plasma cholesterol of 153 mg/dL) or Chol 2 (yielding 359 mg/dL) without or with cholestyramine, vitamin E, or both. Offspring (n=15 to 25 per group) were killed at birth. Maternal hypercholesterolemia enhanced mean lesion size in the aorta of their offspring at birth from 44+/-18x10(3) micrometer(2) per section in controls to 85+/-26x10(3) in Chol 1 and 156+/-49x10(3) in Chol 2 groups (P<0.0001 for both). Cholestyramine or vitamin E treatment of mothers significantly reduced atherosclerosis at birth by up to 39% compared with controls on the same diet. Oxidized fatty acids and malondialdehyde in aortic atherosclerotic lesions and plasma were similarly affected by diets and treatment as atherosclerosis. Our results establish the causal role of hypercholesterolemia and peroxidation in fetal atherogenesis and demonstrate that both lipid-lowering and antioxidant interventions during pregnancy can reduce it. If it can be established that interventions in mothers also affect progression of lesions after birth, this may indicate a novel approach for the prevention of atherosclerosis.