Many bacteria possess type-II immunity against invading phages or plasmids known as the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat (CRISPR)/CRISPR-associated 9 (Cas9) system to detect and degrade the foreign DNA sequences. The Cas9 protein has two endonucleases responsible for double-strand breaks (the HNH domain for cleaving the target strand of DNA duplexes and RuvC domain for the nontarget strand, respectively) and a single-guide RNA-binding domain where the RNA and target DNA strands are base-paired. Three engineered single Lys-to-Ala HNH mutants (K810A, K848A, and K855A) exhibit an enhanced substrate specificity for cleavage of the target DNA strand. We report in this study that in the wild-type (wt) enzyme, D835, Y836, and D837 within the Y836-containing loop (comprising E827-D837) adjacent to the catalytic site have uncharacterizable broadened ¹H¹⁵N nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) features, whereas remaining residues in the loop have different extents of broadened NMR spectra. We find that this loop in the wt enzyme exhibits three distinct conformations over the duration of the molecular dynamics simulations, whereas the three Lys-to-Ala mutants retain only one conformation. The versatility of multiple alternate conformations of this loop in the wt enzyme could help to recruit noncognate DNA substrates into the HNH active site for cleavage, thereby reducing its substrate specificity relative to the three mutants. Our study provides further experimental and computational evidence that Lys-to-Ala substitutions reduce dynamics of proteins and thus increase their stability.