Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) patients have a high risk of converting to Alzheimer's disease. The most common diagnostic subtypes of MCI have an episodic memory disorder (amnestic MCI) occurring either alone [single domain (SD)] or with other cognitive impairments [multiple domain (MD)]. Previous studies report increased amplitudes of auditory cortical potentials in MCI, but their relationships to MCI subtypes and clinical outcomes were not defined. We studied subjects with amnestic MCI (n = 41: 28 SD, 13 MD), Alzheimer's disease (n = 14), and both younger (n = 22) and age-matched older controls (n = 44). Baseline auditory sensory (P50, N100) and cognitive potentials (P300) were recorded during an auditory discrimination task. MCI patients were followed for up to 5 years, and outcomes were classified as (i) continued diagnosis of MCI (MCI-stable, n = 16), (ii) probable Alzheimer's disease (MCI-convert, n = 18), or other outcomes (n = 7). Auditory potentials were analysed as a function of MCI diagnosis and outcomes, and compared with young, older controls, and mild Alzheimer's disease subjects. P50 amplitude increased with normal ageing, and had additional increases in MCI as a function of both initial diagnosis (MD > than SD) and outcome (MCI-convert > MCI-stable). P300 latency increased with normal ageing, and had additional increases in MCI but did not differ among outcomes. We conclude that auditory cortical sensory potentials differ among amnestic MCI subtypes and outcomes occurring up to 5 years later.