Prenol and isoprenol are promising advanced biofuels and serve as biosynthetic precursors for pharmaceuticals, fragrances, and other industrially relevant compounds. Despite engineering improvements that circumvent intermediate cytotoxicity and lower energy barriers, achieving high titer 'mevalonate (MVA)-derived' prenol has remained elusive. Difficulty in selective prenol production stems from the necessary isomerization of isopentenyl diphosphate (IPP) to dimethylallyl diphosphate (DMAPP) as well as the intrinsic toxicity of these diphosphate precursors. Here, the expression of specific isopentenyl monophosphate kinases with model-guided enzyme substitution of diphosphate isomerases and phosphatases enabled selective cycling of monophosphates and diphosphates, dramatically improving prenol titers and selectivity in Escherichia coli. Pairing this approach with the canonical MVA pathway resulted in 300 mg/L prenol at a 30:1 ratio with isoprenol. Further pairing with the "IPP-Bypass" pathway resulted in 526 mg/L prenol at a 72:1 ratio with isoprenol, the highest and purest MVA-derived prenol titer to date. Additionally, modifying this "IPP-Repass" for DMAPP production and coexpressing the prenyltransferase acPT1 yielded 48.3 mg/L of the potential therapeutic precursor drupanin from p-coumarate. These novel repass pathways establish a unique strategy for tuning diphosphate precursors to drive isoprenoid biosynthesis and prenylation reactions.