Beta-guanidinopropionic acid (GPA) is a creatine analog suggested as a treatment for hypertension, diabetes, and obesity, which manifest primarily in older adults. A notable side effect of GPA is the induction of mitochondrial DNA deletion mutations. We hypothesized that mtDNA deletions contribute to muscle aging and used the mutation promoting effect of GPA to examine the impact of mtDNA deletions on muscles with differential vulnerability to aging. Rats were treated with GPA for up to 4 months starting at 14 or 30 months of age. We examined quadriceps and adductor longus muscles as the quadriceps exhibits profound age-induced deterioration, while adductor longus is maintained. GPA decreased body and muscle mass and mtDNA copy number while increasing mtDNA deletion frequency. The interactions between age and GPA treatment observed in the quadriceps were not observed in the adductor longus. GPA had negative mitochondrial effects in as little as 4 weeks. GPA treatment exacerbated mtDNA deletions and muscle aging phenotypes in the quadriceps, an age-sensitive muscle, while the adductor longus was spared. GPA has been proposed for use in age-associated diseases, yet the pharmacodynamics of GPA differ with age and include the detrimental induction of mtDNA deletions, a mitochondrial genotoxic stress that is pronounced in muscles that are most vulnerable to aging. Further research is needed to determine if the proposed benefits of GPA on hypertension, diabetes, and obesity outweigh the detrimental mitochondrial and myopathic side effects.