Table 1: Differences between bullous Darier’s disease and Hailey-Hailey disease1-4,9-12
Bullous Darier’s Disease |
Familial Benign Pemphigus |
I. Genetic |
|
1. Mutation in SERCA 2 gene on chr. 12q 23-24.1 |
Mutation in genes11,12 encoding golgi secretory pathway CA+2 ATPase (SPCA1 ATP2 (1) on chr. 3q 21-q24 |
II Clinical Features |
|
2. Onset in 1st/2nd decade |
Onset in 3rd/4th decade |
3. Males = Females |
Males > Females |
4. Low familial incidence |
High familial incidence |
5. Warty, greasy, malodourous papules Vesicles to bullae present over the seborrhoeic sites. |
Primary lesion is a flaccid vesicles and blisters on flexural sites which soon rupture because of friction and secondary infection. It is more common to find eroded, macerating, vegetating plaques |
6. Lesions develop slowly |
Lesions develop rapidly |
7. Lesions static. Lesions never disappear permanently and progress to involve the entire body |
Lesions disappear entirely, leaving no macroscopic changes except temporary pigmentation. |
8. Recurrence of lesions are not seen because they are irreversible unless specific treatment is initiated |
Recurrence is characteristic10 |
9. Condition worsens in older people progressive |
Condition improves in older people. Attacks are milder and less frequent as years go by |
10. Conjunctiva and cornea not attached |
Conjunctiva and cornea may be attacked and has been reported |
11. Palms and soles involved |
Palms and soles normal |
12. Nails may be involved |
Nails not involved |
13. Nikolsky sign negative |
Nikolsky sign often positive |
III Histology |
|
14. Hyperkeratosis and follicular plugging` |
Usually absent |
15. Suprabasal clefts – smaller |
Larger- lacunae exend laterally |
16. Dyskeratotic cells (corps ronds and grains) more evident |
Less evident |
17. Acantholytic cells: less evident |
More evident. Foci of “dilapidated brick wall appearance “ |
IV Response To Treatment |
|
a) Topical and systemic steroids b) No response to antibiotic treatment c) Oral retinoids have a variable response and in vivo systemic retinoids induce desquamation and skin fragility and aggravate lesions in bullous dariers.
|
a) Topical antibiotics/antifungals – tetracyclines, fusidic acid, imidazoles b) Systemic steroids – short course in case of acute exacerbation c) Other-drugs–dapsone,cyclosporine,Grenz rays d) Methotrexate and retinoids in resistant cases |